03 Oct 2019
By David Marsh
Construction Law

The High Court heard the matter of Mann v Paterson Constructions Pty Ltd [2018] VSCA 231 on 14 May 2019 and will be delivering its decision on 9 October. Lawyers for owners and builders need to be prepared for that decision.

The main issue concerns a builder’s ability to recover money for the entirety of the work performed on a quantum meruit basis as an alternative to contractual damages where the owner repudiates the contract.

Relying on (to a large extent) Renard Constructions (ME) Pty Ltd v Minister for Public Works (1992) 26 NSWLR 234, builders can often recover more money when a Court awards a remedy on a quantum meruit basis. For example, at first instance, in Paterson Constructions Pty Ltd v Mann [2016] VCAT 2100, the Senior Member of the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal allowed the builder to recover $24,000 for scaffolding even though the builder had not provided scaffolding. This was awarded as a result of the builder’s ability to recover the reasonable costs of the works on a quantum meruit basis regardless of whether or not those works were actually performed or those costs incurred.

Watching the hearing, and in particular, the interaction between the bench and the builders’ counsel, Jonathon Moore SC, it seems likely the High Court will overturn Renard Constructions, or at least confine it to a similar effect.

Lawyers representing owners and builders should be watching the High Court next Wednesday. We will post a short case note once it does.

The transcript and video of the hearing can be found here: http://www.hcourt.gov.au/cases/case_m197-2018

David Marsh and Maha Abweh, Solomon Brothers Construction Law

Recent Insights

How to Respond to a Statutory Demand

In this article, we explain what a statutory demand is, the legal consequences of receiving one, and how you can respond to one to receive the best outcome for your company.
Read More

How To Build a Security Of Payments Act Claim and Response

Following recent amendments to the WA Building and Construction Act, claimants and respondents alike may be left asking how these...
Read More

Infrastructure expenditure affecting the Western Australian construction market

Over the last 12 months, there have been numerous reports of a skills shortage in the Western Australian building and construction industry – in both blue and white-collar sectors. While the current boom is nowhere near that of 2012, there are a number of factors making it more difficult to top up the Western Australian building and construction industry from outside sources.
Read More

Are you SOPA Ready?

This week (on 22 June 2021), amendments to the WA regime as set out in the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Bill 2021 were passed by both houses of WA Parliament and is currently awaiting formal assent by Governor. With a Western Australian security of payment regime set to undergo a root and branch overhaul, it is time to ask yourself: Am I SOPA ready?
Read More

Time Bars vs Estoppel: Valmont Interiors Case

At the heart of the appeal was the question of whether an estoppel would operate to prevent a party, which directed additional works outside the express contractual variation regime, from bringing those works back within the contractual variation regime and then using the time bar provisions of that regime to bar the claim.
Read More

Notes on Boilerplate Terms of Contracts Impacting Construction Disputes

This is a short article regarding two dissimilar cases, both of which focus attention on the fact that the boilerplate terms of contracts can have a significant impact on the conduct of construction disputes.
Read More

Commercial Leases in Western Australia during the COVID-19 Pandemic

Acknowledging small business, including the retail sector, have been hard-hit during the COVID-19 pandemic, changes to commercial tenancy laws in WA are providing some relief through what is defined as this “emergency period”. Solomon Brothers partner, Chris Williams, provides a summary of these legislative changes and their impact on both landlords and tenants.
Read More

When Worlds Collide: Indemnities Vs Limitations of Liability

While the usual caveats that apply to the impact of decisions refusing to grant summary judgment apply to NRW Contracting Pty Ltd v Cliffs Asia Pacific Iron Ore Pty Ltd [2020] WASCA 2020, there are at least important take-aways from the decision. The fact that it is a Court of Appeal decision also makes it worthy of note.
Read More

ASIC’s beef with Westpac over responsible lending duties

On 13 August 2019, the Federal Court of Australia handed down its judgment in Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Westpac Banking Corporation (Liability Trial) [2019] FCA 1244 (“the Liability Trial”).
Read More

Commercial Rent Reduction Negotiation: Getting a great result for all parties

What to do when a commercial tenant asks for a rent reduction The starting point for a landlord is to...
Read More

Get in touch with our Construction Law Team


Partner Litigation